Property is often the most valuable asset a person or business owns, so it is no surprise that disagreements over land and buildings can quickly become stressful and expensive. Whether the issue is a neighbour using your driveway, a disputed boundary or a co-owner who refuses to sell, understanding your rights early can make a significant difference to the outcome.

This guide explains the most common types of property disputes in New South Wales, how easements work, and when a person may be able to claim land through adverse possession.

What is Property Litigation?

Property litigation is the process of resolving disputes about the ownership, use, or occupation of land and buildings. In NSW, these disputes may be heard in a number of forums, including the Supreme Court of NSW, the Land and Environment Court, the Local Court and the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NCAT), depending on the nature and value of the matter.

Many property disputes are resolved without going to court, through negotiation or mediation. However, where agreement cannot be reached, litigation may be necessary to protect your interests.

Common Types of Property Disputes in NSW

Property disputes can arise in residential, commercial and rural settings. The most common include:

  • Boundary disputes: disagreements about where one property ends and another begins, often involving fences, retaining walls or structures built over a boundary;
  • Co-ownership disputes: where co-owners cannot agree on whether to sell or how to divide a property, a co-owner may apply to the Supreme Court for the appointment of trustees for sale under section 66G of the Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW);
  • Contract for sale disputes: including failure to complete settlement, rescission and disputes over deposits;
  • Caveat disputes: where a caveat has been lodged on a property’s title, preventing dealings with the land;
  • Dividing fence and tree disputes: which are governed by the Dividing Fences Act 1991 (NSW) and the Trees (Disputes Between Neighbours) Act 2006 (NSW); and
  • Easement disputes: disagreements about access, drainage or services that cross another person’s land.

Easements Explained

An easement is a right held by the owner of one parcel of land to use another person’s land for a particular purpose. The land that benefits from the easement is known as the dominant tenement, while the land burdened by it is known as the servient tenement.

Common examples of easements include:

  • A right of carriageway, allowing access across a neighbour’s driveway;
  • An easement for drainage of water or sewage; and
  • An easement for services, such as electricity, gas or telecommunications.

How are easements created?

In NSW, easements can be created in several ways, including:

  • By express grant in a registered instrument;
  • Through a section 88B instrument registered with a plan of subdivision;
  • By implication, in limited circumstances; and
  • By court order under section 88K of the Conveyancing Act 1919 (NSW).

Court-imposed easements under section 88K

Where a landowner needs an easement but a neighbour will not agree to grant one, the court may impose an easement under section 88K. Generally, the court must be satisfied that:

  • The easement is reasonably necessary for the effective use or development of the land;
  • The use of the land under the easement will not be inconsistent with the public interest;
  • The owner of the burdened land can be adequately compensated; and
  • All reasonable attempts have been made to obtain the easement by agreement.

If an order is made, the applicant will usually be required to pay compensation to the burdened landowner, along with costs.

Easement disputes

Disputes often arise where an easement holder uses the land beyond what the easement permits, where the burdened owner obstructs access, or where one party wants an easement modified or extinguished. The court has power under section 89 of the Conveyancing Act to modify or extinguish an easement in certain circumstances, such as where it has been abandoned or has become obsolete.

Adverse Possession Explained

Adverse possession allows a person who has occupied land without the owner’s permission for a long period to apply to become the registered owner of that land. While often described as “squatters’ rights”, it most commonly arises in boundary situations, such as where a fence has been built in the wrong place for many years.

The 12-year rule

Under the Limitation Act 1969 (NSW), an owner generally has 12 years to take action to recover land from a person in possession of it. Once that period has expired, the owner’s right to recover the land may be extinguished. For Torrens title land, the person in possession can then make a possessory application to NSW Land Registry Services under the Real Property Act 1900 (NSW).

What must be proven?

Adverse possession claims are difficult to establish. The person claiming the land generally needs to show that their possession was:

  • Actual and exclusive, meaning they controlled the land to the exclusion of others, including the owner;
  • Open, rather than secretive;
  • Without the owner’s permission; and
  • Continuous for the full limitation period.

The claimant must also show an intention to possess the land. Simply mowing a neighbour’s lawn or occasionally parking on vacant land is unlikely to be enough. Evidence such as fencing, buildings, statutory declarations from neighbours and historical aerial photographs is often critical.

Limits on adverse possession

Adverse possession claims are subject to important restrictions. For example, the limitation period for land owned by the Crown is significantly longer, and certain public land cannot be claimed at all. If you have been using land with the owner’s permission, your possession will not be “adverse”.

Lawyers can, but are not limited to, assist with the following:

  • Advising on your rights and obligations in boundary, co-ownership and contract disputes;
  • Negotiating, creating, modifying or extinguishing easements;
  • Preparing and opposing applications for court-imposed easements under section 88K;
  • Assessing whether an adverse possession claim is available, or defending your land against one; and
  • Representing you in mediation, NCAT, the Land and Environment Court or the Supreme Court.

Summary

Property disputes in NSW can involve complex legislation and significant financial consequences. Easements and adverse possession in particular involve technical legal tests, and the strength of a claim often depends on detailed evidence gathered over many years.

Seeking legal advice early can help you understand your position, preserve important evidence and resolve the dispute in the most cost-effective way.

Dettmann Phair Lawyers: Your Trusted and Experienced Legal Professionals

At Dettmann Phair Lawyers, our experienced commercial dispute lawyers have engaged in all forms of the dispute resolution process and can assist you with your matter.

To explore your options call one of our expert litigation lawyers at Dettmann Phair Lawyers today on (02) 9412 4500 or complete our enquiry form online.

Author

  • Damian Phair

    Damian Phair, Principal at Dettmann Phair Lawyers, has over 25 years of legal experience across both family and commercial law.

    He is highly regarded for his work in complex family law matters, including parenting disputes, property settlements, and financial agreements, where his pragmatic and client-focused approach have helped families resolve sensitive issues with clarity and care.

    Additionally, his expertise in commercial law, advising businesses on complex agreements, dispute resolution, and litigation, has delivered protection, compliance and long-term success for our clients. His strategic mindset and depth of knowledge allow him to guide companies through high-stakes negotiations and legal challenges, protecting their interests while supporting growth.

    Whether assisting families through personal transitions or businesses navigating commercial complexities, Damian provides clear, practical, and effective legal solutions.

    Email:[email protected] | Phone: 02 9412 4500

    View all posts

About the Author

Damian Phair, Principal at Dettmann Phair Lawyers, has over 25 years of legal experience across both family and commercial law.

He is highly regarded for his work in complex family law matters, including parenting disputes, property settlements, and financial agreements, where his pragmatic and client-focused approach have helped families resolve sensitive issues with clarity and care.

Additionally, his expertise in commercial law, advising businesses on complex agreements, dispute resolution, and litigation, has delivered protection, compliance and long-term success for our clients. His strategic mindset and depth of knowledge allow him to guide companies through high-stakes negotiations and legal challenges, protecting their interests while supporting growth.

Whether assisting families through personal transitions or businesses navigating commercial complexities, Damian provides clear, practical, and effective legal solutions.

Email:[email protected] | Phone: 02 9412 4500